This article begins with the basic question of why a few rocks and a reef called Bajo de Masinloc (Scarborough Shoal) is important to the Philippines. It then presents the basis and evidence of Philippine sovereignty over Bajo de Masinloc, demonstrating that the Philippines does have a better right to it notwithstanding China`s insistence on its claim. Finally, it offers some ideas meant to provoke a serious and sanguine conversation about what the Philippines should do next in relation to our pending issues with China over Bajo de Masinloc, particularly with respect to the Mutual Defense Treaty between the Philippines and the United States.
Keywords: South China Sea disputes, Scarborough Shoal, Bajo de Masinloc, Philippine maritime claims, historical evidenceBajo de Masinloc (Scarborough Shoal): Less known facts vs. published fiction
Arana, Camilo de. (1879). Derrotero del Archipielago Filipino. Madrid: Direccion de Hidrografia. Available at: https://quod.lib.umich.edu/p/philamer/AGX9509.0001.001?view=toc.
Bonnet Francois–Xavier. (2012). Geopolitics of Scarborough Shoal. [Annex 2: Transcriptions of some records, concerning Scarborough Shoal.] In the Bureau of Insular Affairs papers (BIA) in the US National Archives Records Administration (NARA). IRASEC Discussion Paper No. 14, November 2012. Available at: www.irasec.com.
Carr, Carl Robert. (1794). A Chart of the China Sea and Philippine Islands with the Archipelagos of Felicia and Soloo. [map]. London, R. Laurie & J. Whittle. University of the Philippines Library Collection (Dr. Domingo Abella Portfolio). [Original copy: Philippine Map Collectors Society, Private Collection]. Also available at: http://nla.gov.au/nla.obj-230807990/view.
Census of the Philippine Islands taken under the Direction of the Philippine Legislature in the Year 1918. Census Office of the Philippine Islands. Manila: Bureau of Printing, 1920.
Chau Ju-Kua. (1911). “Chu-fan-chi.” Hirth, Frederick and W.W. Rockwell. Trans. St. Petersburg: Print Office of the Imperial Academy of Sciences
“Chinese Embassy. Q&A.” (2012). PhilStar Online. STAR Group of Publications. April 17, 2012. Accessed July 16, 2012 at https://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=797777&publicationSubCategoryId=63.
Clüver, Philipp. (1697). Indiae Orientalis et Insularium Adiacentium. Antiqua et Nova Descriptio. National Library of the Philippines Special Collection. [map]. http://www.imoa.ph/imoawebexhibit/Splices/The%20Historical%20Facts%20in%20the%20WPS-page34.pdf.
Colton, J.R. (1855). Colton’s East Indies. New York. National Library of the Philippines Collection. [map]. Available at: https://nla.gov.au/nla.obj-230616255/view.
Commission of the Census. (1939). Commonwealth of the Philippines: Fishing Banks, January 1, 1939. Manila: Bureau of Coast and Geodetic Surveys. [NAMRIA Library and Documentation Services Collection].
Cox, Alvin (ed.). (1913). The Philippine Journal of Science, 8(A: Chemical and Geological Sciences and the Industries. December 1913). Manila: Bureau of Printing.
D’Anville, Jean Baptiste Bourguignon. (1752). Seconde Partie de la carte d’Asie contenant la Chine et partie de la Tartarie, l’ Inde au dela du Gange, les Isles Sumatra, Java, Borneo, Moluques, Philippines et du Japon. Paris. National Library of the Philippines Special Collection. [map]. Available at: http://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/printheritage/detailmap/fabf76e3-ca97-43e3-ae66-c8b3071b1e77.aspx.
Erlanger & Galinger vs. The Swedish Asiatic Co., G.R. No. L – 10051, March 9, 1916. Philippine Reports, 34:178–209.
Executive Orders and Proclamations issued by the Governor – General of the Philippines during the Year 1913. (1914). Manila: Bureau of Printing.
Garnier, F.A. (1860). Borneo, Iles de la Sonde, Celebes, Moluques, et Philippines. Paris, NAMRIA Library and Documentation Services Collection. [map]. Available at: http://www.imoa.ph/spratlys-puloancient-maps/.
Huddart, Joseph. (1801). The Oriental Navigator, Or, New Directions for Sailing to and from East Indies, China, New Holland, Etc., Etc., Etc. Also for the Use of the Country Ships, Trading in the Idian and China Seas, Pacific Ocean, Etc., Etc., Etc. London: Robert Laurie and James Whittle, Printsellers. Available at: http://www.sabrizain.org/malaya/library/orientalnavigator.pdf.
Kitchin, Thomas. (1769). A New Map of the Philippines Islands drawn from the best authorities. London. National Library of the Philippines Special Collection. [map].
Lotilla, Raphael Perpetuo M. (Ed.). (1995). The Philippine National Territory. Quezon City: UP Institute of International Legal Studies and Foreign Service Institute.
Mariette, Pierre. (1650). Carta Generale des Isles Orientales et des Isles Adjacentes. Paris. Senior Associate Justice Antonio T. Carpio, Private Collection. [map].
Phil – US Mutual Defense Treaty. (Aug. 30, 1951). Available at: https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/1951/08/30/mutual-defense-treatybetween-the-republic-of-the-philippines-and-the-united-states-of-americaaugust-30-1951/.
NAMRIA. (July 8, 1997) Descriptive Report: GPS Survey – Scarborough Shoal. NAMRIA Hydrography Branch Nautical Charting Division Archives Unit.
Philippine Coast Pilot, Part I: Sailing Directions for the Coasts of Luzon, Mindoro and Visayan Islands. (5th Edition). (1968). Department of National Defense, Philippine Coast and Geodetic Survey. Manila: Bureau of Printing.
Philippine Constitution (1935). Available at: https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/constitutions/the-1935-constitution/.
Philippine Constitution. (1973). Available at: https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/constitutions/1973-constitution-of-therepublic-of-the-philippines-2/.
Philippine Constitution. (1987). Available at: https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/constitutions/1987-constitution/.
Philippine Navy. (September 18, 1981). “Notice to Mariners 54/81”. NAMRIA Hydrography Branch Nautical Charting Division Archives Unit. “PN shells Smuggler’s Sea Lair”. (10 October 1963). The Manila Times.
Quan Jin. (1402). Map of the Entire Empire and Frontier Countries. [map].
Report of the Philippine Commission to the Secretary of War, 1913. (1914). Washington: Government Printing Office.
R.A. 9522 (2009). Republic Act No.9522, “An Act to amend certain provisions of Republic Act No. 3046, as amended by Republic Act No. 5446, to define the archipelagic baseline of the Philippines and for other purposes.” Available at: https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/2009/03/10/republic-act-no-9522/.
Robert de Vaugondy. (1750). Archipel des Indes Orientales qui comprend Les Isles de la Sonde, Moloques, et Philippines. Paris, 1750. University of the Philippines University Library Collection (Dr. Domingo Abella Portfolio). [map]. [Original copy: Philippine Map Collectors Society, Private Collection]. Available at: https://quod.lib.umich.edu/c/clark1ic/x-004060251/39015091916695_01.
The United States Coast Pilot: Philippine Islands, Part 1: Luzon, Mindoro and Visayas. (3rd Edition). (1939). Serial No. 613. US Department of Commerce, Coast and Geodetic Survey. Washington: US Government Printing Office.
U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey. (1933). Philippine Islands. [Chart no.] 4200. Manila: U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey. [map].
Velarde, Pedro Murillo. (1734). Carta Hydrographic y Chorographica de Las Islas Filipinas. Manila. [map]. [University of the Philippines University Library (UP Library) Collection, Dr. Francisco Abella Portfolio]. Available at: https://www.loc.gov/resource/g8060.ct003137/?r=-0.559,-0.009,2.118,1.022,0.
Ventura, Antonio. (1961a). Descriptive Report: Hydrographic Survey, Field No. RE – 01161. Department of National Defense, Philippine Coast and Geodetic Survey. NAMRIA Hydrography Branch Nautical Charting Division Archives Unit.
Ventura, Antonio. (1961b). Descriptive Report: Topographic Survey, Field No. RE – A – 01. Department of National Defense, Philippine Coast and Geodetic Survey. NAMRIA Hydrography Branch Nautical Charting Division Archives Unit.
Wilkinson, Robert. (1801). The Islands of the East Indies with the Channels between India, China, New Holland, etc. London: Laurie and Whittle [map].
Zou Keyuan. (1999). “Scarborough Reef: A New Flashpoint in SinoPhilippine Relations?” IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin 7(2):71-81.