Public health crises, such as the current COVID-19 pandemic that the world is currently experiencing, highlight two undeniable truths, among others. One is the value of health and healthcare, which is necessary for our survival, well-being, and access to some of life’s opportunities. The other is the scarcity of most healthcare resources. As everybody’s healthcare needs will not be satisfied, misfortunes in the form of suffering, loss of opportunities, or death are bound to occur. In the face of such realities, the issue of justice in healthcare, which inquires into what makes healthcare resource allocations fair, becomes a serious moral concern. This essay critically examines two philosophical approaches to this issue: the utilitarian approach, which aims to promote our greatest overall welfare, and the fair equality of opportunity approach, which aims to promote equality in our access to life’s normal range of opportunities. Despite their differences and challenges, it is shown that they can be combined to form a more comprehensive account of justice in healthcare and, consequently, serve as a practical moral framework for drafting or evaluating prioritization guidelines for allocating scarce healthcare resources in a COVID-19 pandemic.
Keywords: justice, healthcare, equality of opportunity, utilitarianism, pandemic, COVID-19Aguilera, B. (2020). Ethical allocation of scarce health-care resources in the context of the COVID-19 crisis. Medwave, 20(5), 1–5. https://doi.org/10.5867/medwave.2020.05.7935
Boyd, K. M., & Potter, B. T. (1986). Priorities in the allocation of scarce resources. Journal of Medical Ethics, 12(4), 197–200. https://www.jstor.org/stable/27716531
Buchanan, A. (1981). Justice: A philosophical review. In E. Shelp (Ed.), Justice and health care (pp. 3-22). D. Reidel Publishing Company.
Buchanan, A. (2009a). Health-care delivery and resource allocation. In A. Buchanan (Ed.), Justice and health care: Selected essays (pp. 37–76). Oxford University Press.
Buchanan, A. (2009b). The right to a decent minimum of health care. In A. Buchanan (Ed.), Justice and health care: Selected essays (pp. 17–36). Oxford University Press.
Caufield, T., & Ries, N. (2006). The allocation of organs: Emerging legal issues. Canadian Council for Donation and Transplantation (pp. 1-12).
Childress, J. (1981). Priorities in the allocation of health care resources. In E. Shelp (Ed.), Justice and health care (pp. 151–160). D. Reidel Publishing Company.
Daniels, N. (1981). Health-care needs and distributive justice. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 10(2), 146–179.
Daniels, N. (1985). Just health care. Cambridge University Press.
Daniels, N. (2001). Justice, health, and healthcare. American Journal of Bioethics, 1(2), 2–16.
https://doi.org/10.1162/152651601300168834
Daniels, N. (2009). Is there a right to health care and, if so, what does it encompass? In H. Kuhse & P. Singer (Eds.), A companion to bioethics (2nd ed.; pp. 362–372). Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
Emanuel, E. et al. (2020). Fair allocation of scarce medical resources in the time of Covid-19. The New England Journal of Medicine, 382(21), 2049–2055. https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmsb2005114
Evangelista, F., & Mabaquiao, N. (2020). Ethics: Theories and applications. Anvil Publishing, Inc.
Fried, C. (1976). Equality and rights in medical care. Hastings Center Report, 6(1), 29–34. https://doi.org/10.2307/3560359
Hare, R. M. (2009). A utilitarian approach. In H. Kuhse & P. Singer (Eds.), A companion to bioethics (2nd ed.; pp. 85–90). Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
Harris, J. (2009). Deciding between patients. In H. Kuhse & P. Singer (Eds.), A companion to bioethics (pp. 335–350; 2nd ed.). Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
Mill, J. S. (2004). Utilitarianism. In H. Gensler (Ed.), Ethics: Contemporary readings (pp. 196–201). Routledge.
Nozick, R. (1993). Distributive justice. In T. White (Ed.), Business ethics: A philosophical reader (pp. 100–109). Macmillan Publishing Company.
Peter, F. (2001). Health equity and social justice. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 18(2), 159–170. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-5930.00183
Rawls, J. (1993). A theory of justice. In T. White (Ed.), Business ethics: A philosophical reader (pp. 89–99). Macmillan Publishing Company.
Rawls, J. (1971). A theory of justice. Harvard University Press.
Ruger, J. P. (2009). Health and social justice. Oxford University Press.
Sen, A. (2002). Why health equity? Health Economics, 11(8), 659–666. https://doi.org/10.1002/hec.762
Silvers, A. (1988). A fatal attraction to normalizing: Treating disabilities as deviations from "species-typical functioning.” In E. Parens (Ed.), Enhancing human traits: Ethical and social implications (pp. 162–176). Georgetown University Press.
Smith, G. P. (2008). Distributive justice and the new medicine. Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
Sreenivasan, G. (2007). Health care and equality of opportunity. Hastings Center Report, 37(2), 21–31. https://doi.org/10.1353/hcr.2007.0033
Stern, L. (1983). Opportunity and health care: Criticisms and suggestions. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 8(4), 339–361. https://doi.org/10.1093/jmp/8.4.339