Having access to research-based materials is an essential component for designing effective interventions for low-achieving and disadvantaged students. The purpose of this study was to compare the effectiveness of two types of reading material intervention for low-achieving and disadvantaged students. The students were divided into experimental (n = 29) and control (n = 27) groups. The students in the control group received the alternative remediation program provided by the school. The experimental group was divided into two subgroups: 19 students received “auxiliary” reading remediation materials (the AUX group), while the other 10 received “adjusted” reading remediation materials (the ADJ group). Data were gathered from the pre and post-test results of a variety of reading and writing tests. There were three major findings. First, both the AUX and ADJ groups showed advantages in attaining results, but there were no significant differences between them in terms of promoting language skills. Furthermore, the AUX group had a slight advantage with regard to overall progress and peer catch-up rate, while the ADJ group showed higher effectiveness than the AUX group in the enhancement of academic performance. Second, the language skills of the students in the two experimental groups have relatively closed the gap with the norm. Specifically, over 50 % of the students in the AUX group achieved peer-level character recognition and dictation abilities in the second-term posttest. Third, both experimental groups demonstrated better reading skills than the control group, but there were no significant differences in terms of reading comprehension. Implications of the study will be discussed based on the findings from this study.
Keywords: Disadvantaged students Remedial instruction Auxiliary reading remediation materials Adjusted reading remediation materialsChall, J. S. (1996). Qualitative assessment of text difficulty: A practical guide for teachers and writers. Cambridge, Mass: Brookline Books.
Chang, S.-J., & Han, M.-J. (2004). The effects of different word recognition teaching methods for lower grade elementary school students. Educational Review, 22, 71–88. (Text in Chinese).
Chen, S.-L. (2008a). The road of literacy for disadvantaged children: Understanding and reform of after-school learning. Taipei: Wu-Nan. (Text in Chinese).
Chen, S.-L. (2008b). The effectiveness of a remedial reading program for second graders: A case of long-term intensive intervention. Bulletin of Special Education, 33(2), 25–45. (Text in Chinese).
Chen, S.-L., Hung, L.-Y., Tzeng, S.-J., & Chung, M.-H. (2006). Developing a remedial reading program for Taiwanese aboriginal students: A preliminary study. Contemporary Educational Research Journal, 14(4), 63–98. (Text in Chinese).
Chen, S.-L., Tzeng, S.-J., & Chiang, L.-M. (2012). The effects of a tier 1 plus tier 2 reading intervention on low-achieving disadvantaged schools: The comparison between different intervention durations. Bulletin of Special Education, 37(3), 27–58. (Text in Chinese).
Chu, C.-Y., Huang, H.-S., & Chen, H.-P. (2013). A case study of the observation of teaching methods from “After School Alternative Program”. Curriculum and Instruction Quarterly, 16(1), 93–114. (Text in Chinese).
Ehri, L. C., Dreyer, L. G., Flugman, B., & Gross, A. (2007). Reading rescue: An effective tutoring intervention model for language-minority students who are struggling readers in first grade. American Educational Research Journal, 44(2), 414–448.
Foorman, B. R., & Torgesen, J. (2001). Critical elements of classroom and small-group instruction promote reading success in all children. Learning Disabilities Research and Practice, 16, 203–212.
Huang, Y.-J. (2003). The construction and assessment of the new occupational prestige and socioeconomic scores for Taiwan: The indigenization of the social science and sociology of education research. Bulletin of Educational Research, 49(4), 1–31. (Text in Chinese).
Huang, P.-J. (2009). Theory and practice of teaching Chinese characters. Taipei: Yueh-Hsueh. (Text in Chinese).
Huang, C.-H. (2011). To investigate learning effects of pre-referral word recognition intervention for 1st graders with word recognition difficulties-III. Journal of Pingtung University of Education, 37, 129–173. (Text in Chinese).
Hung, L.-Y. (Ed.). (2005). Basic reading and writing remedial materials. Taipei: Department of Special Education, National Taiwan Normal University. (Text in Chinese).
Hung, L.-Y., (2006). Reading Comprehension Test. Unpublished. (Text in Chinese).
Hung, L.-Y., Chang, Y.-F., Chen, S.-F., & Li, Y.-D. (2003). Comprehensive test of basic reading and writing skills. Taipei: Psychological Publishing Co. (Text in Chinese).
Hung, L.-Y., & Huang, K.-Y. (2006). Two different approaches to radical-based remedial Chinese reading for low-achieving beginning readers in primary school. Bulletin of Special Education, 31, 43–71. (Text in Chinese).
Hung, L.-Y., Wang, C.-C., Chang, Y.-W., & Chen, S.-F. (2006a). Word recognition test. Taipei, Taiwan: Ministry of Education. (Text in Chinese).
Hung, L.-Y., Wang, C.-C., Chang, Y.-W., & Chen, S.-F. (2006b). Sight word fluency test. Taipei, Taiwan: Ministry of Education. (Text in Chinese).
Ko, H.-W. (1999). Reading comprehension difficulty screening test. Taipei Taiwan: Ministry of Education. (Text in Chinese).
Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) (2012). Equity and quality in education: Supporting disadvantaged students and schools. OECD Publishing.
Tang, W.-L., & Tsai, P.-J. (2013). An action research on a principal’s promotion of after school alternative Programs using remedial instruction. Curriculum and Instruction Quarterly, 16(1), 69–92. (Text in Chinese).
Torgesen, J. K. (2000). Individual differences in response to early interventions in reading: The lingering problem of treatment resisters. Learning Disabilities Research and Practice, 15, 55–64.
Torgesen, J. K., Alexander, A., Wagner, R., Rashotte, C., Voeller, K., & Conway, T. (2001). Intensive remedial instruction for children with severe reading disabilities: Immediate and long term outcomes from two instructional approaches. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 34(1), 33–58.
Wang, C.-C. (2005). A character identification program for students with reading disabilities. Journal of Taipei Municipal Teachers College, 36(1), 95–124. (Text in Chinese).
Wang, C.-C. (2013). Review of literature on character and vocabulary instruction studies in Taiwan. Bulletin of Educational Psychology, 44(2), 253–272. (Text in Chinese).
Wu, Y.-I. (2007). Effects of school and non-school factors on aboriginal and non-aboriginal elementary students’ academic achievement in Taitung. Taiwan Journal of Sociology of Education, 7(1), 29–67. (Text in Chinese).
Wu, W.-T., Tsai, C.-C., Hu, S.-T., Wang, C.-D., Lin, S.-T., & Kuo, C.-T. (2002). Test of nonverbal intelligence (2nd ed.). Taipei: Psychological Publishing Co. (Text in Chinese).